Claims Reporting

Submit a Property & Liability Claim

Please report all property and liability claims to Tara Shockley our claims manager. She can be reached during normal business hours by phone 302-674-3500 ext 235 or via email here

Submit Benefits Related Claims

Please report all benefits related claims to Jessica Hodges during normal business hours by phone 302-674-3500 ext 229 or via email here.

Our aim is to always walk with you through the claims process, however in case of an emergency you can reach your provider directly using the contact information below. 

Logo for Aetna Health Care


Logo for Allied Insurance company

Personal: (800) 282-1446
Commercial:(866) 322-3214

Logo for AmTrust Financial

(866) 272-9267

Logo for AIG Chartis

(877) 867-3783

Logo for ASI Progressive


Logo for Cincinnati Financial Corporation

(877) 242-2544

Logo for Cumberland Mutual

(866) 794-6399

Logo for Donegal Insurance Group

(800) 877-9006

Logo for Eastern Alliance

(800) 336-3658

Logo for The Hanover Insurance Group

(800) 628-0250

Logo for Harford Mutual Insurance Group

(877) 445-5826

Logo for Harleysville Nationwide Insurance company

(800) 892-8877

Logo for Highmark Delaware


Logo for Liberty Mutual Insurance

(888) 951-0178

Logo for Main Street America Insurance

(877) 425-2467

Logo for Nationwide


Logo for Penn National Insurance

(800) 492-1205

Logo for Principal


Logo for Progressive


Logo for The Hartford

(800) 553-1710

Logo for Travelers

(800) 252-4633

Logo for United Healthcare


Logo for Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company


Logo for Utica National Insurance Group

(800) 284-3806

Logo for Westfield Group

(800) 443-3311

Logo for Zurich

(800) 987-3373